Penny L. Bodnar

penny bodnar

July 6, 1943 ~ August 9, 2025

Born in: Martins Ferry, Ohio
Resided in: Perry, Ohio

Penny L. Bodnar, 82, of Perry, passed suddenly on Saturday, August 9, 2025. She was born on July 6, 1943 to Louis and Elizabeth “Bettie” (Ashton) Sabo in Martins Ferry, Ohio.

Penny graduated from Riverside High School in 1961, and was employed as a secretary receptionist for 10 years at the Madison YMCA. She later became the proud owner of PennyLane Gift Shoppe on Lane Road in Perry, Ohio. She had a passion for her shop, and loved talking to her customers, going on merchandise-buying trips, and dressing her concrete geese in all kinds of festive outfits. She was married to her husband of 59 years, Frank “Buck” Bodnar Jr. They lived together on Townline Road in Madison for 33 years before moving to Perry in 2001. She also loved spending time with her grandchildren, gardening, watching the birds, and watching Jeopardy with the grandkids. She was known to be an avid baker, and loved spending holidays with family.

Penny is survived by her loving husband, Frank; her children, Rebecca Jane Bodnar (Daren Whetstone), Jeffrey Andrew Bodnar (Yrral Belanger), Gretchen (Daniel Jr.) Jekutis; grandchildren, Jaren (Trinity) Bodnar, Gavin and Melina Costello, and Eva Bodnar-Whetstone; sister, Connie Sue (Ron) Hamilton; and many beloved cousins and in-laws. She is preceded in death by her parents.

Friends and family will be received on Wednesday, August 13, from 5-7PM at Behm Family Funeral Home, 26 River Street, Madison OH, 44057. An informal committal with family and friends will take place on Thursday, August 14, 2025, at 10AM in Perry Cemetery.

Online obituary and guestbook at www.behmfuneral.com

Services

Visitation: Wednesday, August 13, 2025 5:00 pm - 7:00 pm

Behm Family Funeral Homes - Madison
26 River Street,
Madison, OH 44057

(440) 428-4401

Graveside Service: Thursday, August 14, 2025 10:00 am - 11:00 am

Perry Cemetery
Center Road
Perry, OH 44081

440-259-5140

View current weather.

Memories Timeline

Guestbook

  1. Father, I pray that You would surround these children with a community of love and support, that they would find solace in the arms of those who care for them. Give them the courage to express their emotions, to grieve openly, and to find healing in the midst of their pain. Help them to remember their mother with love and gratitude, cherishing the memories they shared and finding peace in knowing that she will always be with them in their hearts.

  2. Couldn’t have asked for a better Mother
    Sorry for all the grief and headaches I caused for you over the years.
    I will miss you so much
    May you rest in peace
    Love always,
    Jeffrey

  3. Buck and family,
    We are so sorry to hear of Penny’s death. She certainly will be missed by all who loved her. Keep her precious memories close to your heart today and the days ahead as it will help heal your broken hearts. May Penny rest in peace.

    Gary and Joan Sabo

  4. Jeff & Family

    May our Lord guide you today, tomorrow, and each new day ahead as you remember your Mom with a warmth in your heart and a smile on your face. Your Larchdale family is here for you.

    Many gentle hugs
    Jim & Jacki Lanham


Sign the Guestbook, Light a Candle